• العربية
  • فارسی
Brand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo

European Powers Submit Iran Censure Motion to IAEA Board

Negar Mojtahedi
Negar Mojtahedi

Iran International

Jun 4, 2024, 01:40 GMT+1Updated: 16:40 GMT

Britain, France, and Germany, also known collectively as the E3, submitted a resolution to the United Nations nuclear watchdog’s Board of Governors Monday censuring Iran.

E3 diplomats reportedly cited Iran’s lack of cooperation with the agency, fearing Iran is trying to develop a nuclear weapon. The Islamic Republic has repeatedly denied that claim, insisting its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes.

A diplomatic source told Agence France-Presse (AFP) that the censure has been formally tabled, claiming an “urgency” to react to the situation.

The draft resolution seen by AFP reportedly demands Iran readmit IAEA inspectors and restore camera surveillance at nuclear sites.

The E3’s plan to censure Iran is a "bold move and a remarkable turn of events," according to Andrea Stricker, the Deputy Director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD)’s Nonproliferation and Biodefense program.

“The E3 moving ahead on its own by itself is fascinating,” said Stricker.

“Typically, they [E3] won’t pursue censure unless Washington goes along with it. We don't know yet if Washington is going to vote for the censure or abstain,” she added.

Jason Brodsky, the policy director of United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI), believes the Europeans are frustrated with the US policy on Iran.

"I think they sense that US policy is adrift. That we have no strategy as it relates to the Islamic Republic, particularly with respect to its nuclear program, and that the status quo of inaction amid a series of Iranian escalatory behaviors," Brodsky told Iran International.

The development comes amid heightened tensions over Iran's nuclear capabilities.

A recent confidential International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) report, reviewed by Iran International and other media outlets, warned Iran is continuing to enrich uranium to near weapons-grade levels.

According to the report, Iran’s estimated stockpile of enriched uranium had reached more than 30 times the limit set out in the 2015 nuclear agreement between Tehran and the world powers.

Uranium enriched to 60 percent is close to the levels of 90 percent needed for atomic weapons.

A recent report from the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) alleged the US was pressuring its European allies not to confront Iran on its nuclear program. The report stated that the US and Europe were at odds on how to deal with Iran.

But US officials said that Washington was tightly coordinating with its E3 allies to contain Iran.

In a previous interview with Iran International, Behnam Ben Taleblu, a senior fellow at the FDD, said the fact that there has not been a resolution of censure for more than a year demonstrates the US is not on the same page with its E3 allies when it comes to Iran’s nuclear ambitions.

At the time, US officials said no decision had been taken with respect to the Board of Governors meeting.

Stricker told Iran International the move by Britain, France and Germany to censure Iran suggests the nations' approach to Iran drastically differs from that of the Biden administration.

“The E3 is realizing that the Biden administration's approach and previously the European approach to Iran, which is to de-escalate tensions, to try to use diplomacy to get them to restrain their nuclear advances, is not yielding any sort of benefits,” she said.

The IAEA said Iran is the only non-nuclear weapon state to enrich uranium to such levels.

On Monday, IAEA Director General Rafael Mariano Grossi said the agency “has lost continuity of knowledge in relation to the production centrifuges, rotors and bellows, heavy water, and uranium.”

"Public statements made in Iran regarding its technical capabilities to produce nuclear weapons and possible changes to Iran’s nuclear doctrine only increase my concerns about the correctness and completeness of Iran’s safeguards declarations,” said Grossi during a session with the IAEA Board of Governors.

On Saturday, Ali Shamkhani, a political advisor to Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, warned on X that if “some misguided European countries... adopt a hostile stance towards Iran... at the board, they will face a serious and effective response from our country."

Brodsky believes Iran will respond to the censure resolution.

"I think what the US and its E3 allies do in response to that escalation is going to be equally as important as the resolution. Let's not forget that what I think has been deeply harmful in this entire debate over the censure resolution as it became public that the United States was hesitant or opposed to a censure resolution. I think that Ayatollah Khamenei is a keen judge of the US will."

Russia’s ambassador to the international organizations in Vienna also posted to X this weekend, claiming that a “anti-Iranian resolution” could pose the risk of "seriously deteriorating the situation”.

Negotiations on Iran's nuclear program are on hold after the death of Iran’s president Ebrahim Raisi in a helicopter crash last month near the border with Azerbaijan.

In a presser Monday in Beirut, Iran's acting Foreign Minister Ali Bagheri Kani said exchanges of messages and consultations are still underway with the United States.

The Associated Press reported last month that Bagheri held indirect talks in Oman with Brett McGurk, an adviser to Biden, through Omani officials over heightened tensions in the region.

Most Viewed

US terminates green cards of 3 Iranians tied to Islamic Republic
1

US terminates green cards of 3 Iranians tied to Islamic Republic

2
PODCAST

Worst outcome is Islamic Republic’s survival, ex-CIA official says

3
ANALYSIS

Iran brings unusually broad team to US talks to blunt future blame

4
INSIGHT

Tehran sends tough message but keeps diplomacy door open

5

Zoroastrian religious figure arrested in Iran

Banner
Banner

Spotlight

  • Tehran sends tough message but keeps diplomacy door open
    INSIGHT

    Tehran sends tough message but keeps diplomacy door open

  • Worst outcome is Islamic Republic’s survival, ex-CIA official says
    PODCAST

    Worst outcome is Islamic Republic’s survival, ex-CIA official says

  • Why the Iran-US truce is more likely to buy time than peace
    ANALYSIS

    Why the Iran-US truce is more likely to buy time than peace

  • Engaged but uncommitted: China watches Iran and US fight and talk
    ANALYSIS

    Engaged but uncommitted: China watches Iran and US fight and talk

  • A truce for the world, a reckoning for Iran’s economy
    ANALYSIS

    A truce for the world, a reckoning for Iran’s economy

  • Why the world failed to bypass the Strait of Hormuz
    ANALYSIS

    Why the world failed to bypass the Strait of Hormuz

•
•
•

More Stories

Iran Executes 67 in May, Targeting Ethnic Minorities and Juveniles

Jun 3, 2024, 20:09 GMT+1

Iranian authorities have executed 67 people in one month, bringing the total number of executions in the country to 246 since the start of 2024, according to human rights organization Hengaw.

More than half of those executed were from ethnic minorities, underscoring concerns about systematic discrimination by Iranian authorities and the utilization of capital punishment as a means of oppression.

In its monthly report, Hengaw stated that out of the dozens executed, 25 were Kurdish, 15 were Turkish, 5 were Baluch, and 3 were Afghan.

Underscoring the alarming rate of executions among Baluch minorities in Iran, the human rights group Haalvsh disclosed on Sunday that 171 Baluch citizens were executed in various prisons across the country between March 2023 and March 2024.

The latest figures follow an Amnesty International report showing that Iran led a surge in recorded executions in 2023, with at least 853 people executed. Amnesty notes these figures represent only the official count, suggesting the actual number could be much higher.

The report also highlighted a significant disparity: although the Baluchi minority constitutes about 5% of Iran's population, they accounted for 20% of the executions in 2023.

Among the prisoners executed in May was Ramin Saadat, a juvenile offender. His execution has raised significant concerns about Iran's compliance with international treaties it has ratified, such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Despite its proclaimed commitment to protecting the rights of minors, the Iranian authorities' continued execution of juvenile offenders highlights a clear disregard for these obligations.

Also among those executed last month, were at least four women: Fariba Mohammadzahi in Kerman prison, Razieh in Vakil Abad prison in Mashhad, Parveen Mousavi in Urmia prison, and Fateme Abdullahpour in Neishabur prison.

Drug-related charges accounted for 38 of the executions, constituting more than half of all cases. Additionally, 26 individuals were executed for premeditated murder, representing a significant portion of the total. Furthermore, two individuals were executed for their religious beliefs.

Iran's judicial process is often criticized for its lack of independence, transparency, and fairness, with prisoners frequently denied legal due process and, in many cases, convicted on fabricated charges.

The United Nations and various human rights organizations have repeatedly called on Iran to halt executions.

Despite these appeals, Amnesty's report revealed that in 2023, Iran accounted for 74% of the 1,153 executions recorded globally.

IRGC 'Advisor' Killed in Syria During Israeli Bombing

Jun 3, 2024, 17:42 GMT+1

Iranian government media report that a Revolutionary Guard "advisor", Saeed (Saeid) Abyar was killed in an Israeli air strike near Aleppo, the second largest city in Syria early Monday.

Earlier in the day, Syrian state media reported that an unknown number of people were killed in an Israeli air strike.

Abyar's rank is not clear, but the his designation as an advisor points to his likely high rank as an officer in the IRGC.

Iran claims its forces in Syria are advisors invited by the Syrian government, while since 2011 it has sent thousands of Iran, Afghan, Iraq and Pakistani militias to fight to defend President Bashar al-Assad against his opponents in the country's civil war.

This was the second reported attack on the country in less than a week, following a string of air strikes since the October 7 Hamas invasion of Israel. Some sources said the targets were affiliated with Iranian-backed forces in the region. Israel usually does not comment about its air strikes in Syria.

The strikes at around 12:20 a.m. early Monday (2120 GMT on Sunday) "led to a number of fatalities and some material damage", the source said, without elaborating. Independent sources have not reported more details so far.

A devastating air strike on April 1 flattened a building in the Iranian diplomatic compound in Damascus, where two senior Revolutionary Guard generals and five other officers died. Reportedly, these individuals were involved in operations aimed at intensifying attacks on Israel. This led to a massive Iranian missile and drone retaliatory attack against Israel on April 13, which inflicted minimal damage. Most projectiles were shot down.

UN Nuclear Chief Says It Is out of Touch with Iran's Expanding Program

Jun 3, 2024, 14:13 GMT+1

The UN's nuclear chief, Rafael Grossi, admitted the agency "has lost continuity of knowledge in relation to the production centrifuges, rotors and bellows, heavy water, and uranium" as Iran's nuclear program expands unabated.

During a session with the IAEA Board of Governors, Director-General Grossi stated, "Public statements made in Iran regarding its technical capabilities to produce nuclear weapons and possible changes to Iran’s nuclear doctrine only increase my concerns about the correctness and completeness of Iran’s safeguards declarations." 

In response to Iran International about the proposed resolution by three European countries against the Islamic Republic, Grossi stated that the member countries must express their opinions on the matter and that the Agency is only obliged to comply with it if the resolution is approved.

Before the Board of Governors meeting, three diplomats told Reuters that three European countries have shared the draft text of their resolution with the member countries of the International Atomic Energy Agency.

Grossi commented on Iran's non-compliance with the Additional Protocol and Shamkhani's threat to stop cooperating with the Agency if a resolution is issued in the Board of Governors, saying that Iran will continue to cooperate with the Agency due to its legal obligations as a member of the NPT.

Grossi articulated concerns stemming from recent public declarations in Iran that hint at a potential doctrinal shift, which may no longer consider nuclear weapons as prohibited by Islam, as earlier claimed by the Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei. The shift comes amid provocations from top Iranian officials who have hinted at a reconsideration of the religious ban on nuclear arms.

The Director-General also expressed regret over Iran’s recent decision to continue barring several key IAEA inspectors from the country after inspectors detected uranium enrichment levels near weapon-grade in early 2022. The discovery revealed that Iran had enriched uranium to 84% in February 2022, nearing the 90% threshold considered weapons-grade. Just weeks ago, Grossi also warned Iran is "weeks not months" away from a nuclear weapon.

Grossi lamented that his recent efforts to foster cooperation were undermined, not least by the death of Iranian Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian. He acknowledged ongoing dialogues with other Iranian officials, including Vice-President Mohammad Eslami, but noted that substantial obstacles remain.

Admitting that Iran's uranium enrichment continues to intensify, Grossi said, "We know that Iran is considering a number of activities which require construction of new facilities, installing new cascades, among other things". In the Monday press conference, Grossi stressed the severity of the situation as the program continues unabated. "They should be informing us of these changes," he said. 

Grossi pointed out that it has been over three years since Iran ceased applying its Additional Protocol, restricting the IAEA’s ability to perform comprehensive inspections. "There has been no progress in resolving the outstanding safeguards issues," he stated, mentioning unresolved queries regarding traces of uranium found at undeclared sites in Varamin and Turquzabad.

On Saturday, ahead of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Board of Governors meeting, Iran issued a warning regarding a possible censure resolution. Ali Shamkhani, a senior aide to Iran's Supreme Leader and reported head of Iran's nuclear negotiations, declared that Iran would deliver a "serious and effective response" if European countries advanced a resolution criticizing its nuclear program.

While publicly, Iran has consistently maintained that its uranium enrichment is solely for civilian purposes and denies any ambitions to develop nuclear weapons, in recent weeks, senior Iranian officials have warned they might reconsider Tehran’s nuclear doctrine if faced with an attack.

It comes as the shadow war between Iran and its archenemy Israel came out into the open in April when Iran launched its first ever direct attack on the Jewish state. Over 350 drones and missiles were launched, mostly intercepted by Israel and a US-led coalition, but taking the years-long proxy war to a new level in which nuclear weaponry became a viable threat.

Iran’s Dairy and Meat Consumption Plummets Amid Escalating Poverty

Jun 3, 2024, 13:16 GMT+1
•
Dalga Khatinoglu

Over the last decade, Iranians have cut dairy consumption by 30% and meat by 17%, amid escalating poverty largely caused by the government's inefficient economic policies.

This month, Mohammad Reza Bani-Taba, the spokesman for Iran’s Dairy Industry Association, announced that per capita milk and dairy consumption in Iran has dropped to 70 kg/year, which is less than half the global average.

Bani-Taba did not specify the exact extent of the decline in dairy and milk consumption in recent years, nor did he clarify whether this reduction has been gradual or abrupt.

Iranians' milk and dairy products consumption (Kg per capita annually)
100%

According to statistics of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), the country’s per capita milk and dairy products consumption declined from 101 kg in 2010 to 70 kg in 2023.

While dietary habits vary across cultures, it is noteworthy that in neighboring Turkey, citizens consume 3.5 times more milk and dairy products than Iranians.

Turkey produces over 21 million tons of milk and dairy products annually, yet exports less than 0.5 million tons. In contrast, Iran, with only a third of Turkey's production, exports four times more than its western neighbor.

Iran’s milk and dairy products exports have surged by 500% in recent years, driven by plummeting domestic demand and the termination of the school milk distribution program. The government ceased free milk distribution in schools in the mid-2010s, significantly boosting exports. However, in late 2023, the government announced plans to reinstate the free milk program in schools.

Iran's milk and dairy products market
100%
Iran's milk and dairy products market

On meat consumption, FAO statistics indicate that consumption per capita in Iran has decreased from 38.6 kg in 2010 to 31.8 kg in 2023, reflecting a 17% decline.

Meat has experienced the highest inflation among food items in recent years, with prices surging above 100% in mid-2023. Just last month, meat prices saw a 74% year-on-year increase.

Official statistics also reveal a 22% decline in daily per capita calorie intake in Iran, dropping to 2,100 calories since the 2010s, with the situation worsening each year.

According to a 2023 report by the semi-official ILNA news agency, one-third of Iran’s population now lives in extreme poverty, with this number nearly doubling from 2020 to 2021.

However, the real figure is likely much higher. Official statistics from the Interior Ministry indicate that around 60% of Iranians live below the relative poverty line.

Iranian Acting FM Calls Lebanese Hezbollah 'Anchor of Stability and Peace'

Jun 3, 2024, 12:34 GMT+1

Iran’s acting Foreign Minister, Ali Bagheri Kani, has called Iran's proxy terror group Hezbollah in Lebanon an "anchor of stability and peace in the region" while the militia continues to bombard Israel's northern towns.

Calling the group, designated by countries including the UK and US the "Islamic Resistance", he lauded the actions which have seen well over 3,000 drones, rockets and missiles launched towards Israel since Iran-backed Hamas launched its invasion on Israel on October 7. Over 100,000 people in Israel's north have been displaced by the conflict and similar numbers from southern Lebanon.

In his first international visit following the sudden death of President Ebrahim Raisi and foreign minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian in a helicopter crash last month, Bagheri arrived in Lebanon on Monday.

Hezbollah, Iran's biggest and most powerful proxy, funded, trained and armed by the regime, continues its daily exchanges of fire with Israeli forces amidst the ongoing Gaza war, the conflict on Israel's northern border its worst since the second Lebanon war.

Bagheri Kani’s visit marks the importance of Lebanon in Iran's 'Axis of Resistance', the collective name used to describe its proxies fighting Iran's archenemies, the US and Israel. With tens of thousands of militants and over 120,000 missiles ready to fire at Israel, Hezbollah remains Iran's greatest proxy project to date, a pet project of the Supreme Leader.

Hezbollah has supported Hamas since the invasion of October 7, along with Iran's proxies in Syria, Yemen, Iraq and Gaza, with missiles fired towards all of Israel's borders. In a single day, around 3,000 Hamas terrorists killed at least 1,200 mostly civilians and took around 250 more hostage to the strip.

Israel's relentless retaliatory attacks have seen over 36,000 killed in Gaza, according to Hamas, Israel claiming 14,000 or more terrorists have been killed in the operation.